Indo-Pacific Economic Conclave, 28th & 29th September 2023, Bengal Chamber Premises
On 28th September, Bengal Chamber of Commerce and Industry in association with the Ministry of External Affairs presented the Indo-Pacific Economic Conclave, an event of paramount significance that aimed to bring together countries in the Indo-Pacific region. The significance of cross border participation lies in initializing dialogue to foster cooperation and interaction between entities, organizations, or individuals from different countries or regions. This collaboration can occur in various fields, including business, resource optimization, innovation, economic growth and much more.
The Bengal Chamber premise was glorified with the branding of Indo-Pacific Economic Conclave, these programme brandings were also spread across the city. All these creative efforts contributed a great amount to the success of Indo-Pacific Economic Conclave. Some pictures are appended below, of the brandings across Kolkata and at the venue.
The theme for Day 1 Indo-Pacific Economic Conclave 2023 was “COLLABORATION AND COOPERATION TOWARDS COMMON GOALS IN THE INDO-PACIFIC”.
Discussions between the Chambers of Commerce, Business Associations and representatives of multilateral agencies, revolved around collaborating and contributing towards fields like trade, supply chain, green economy and fair economies.
The Knowledge Partner of the Conclave, Intueri Global LLP had released a Position Paper on Indo-Pacific Economic Unity.
Inaugural Session
The Inaugural address was delivered by Mr. Subir Chakraborty, Immediate Past President, BCC&I and Managing Director & CEO, Exide Industries Ltd. He Said,
Bengal Chamber of Commerce and Industry is honoured and privileged to have esteemed guests and leaders from business and government from 11 nations – Australia, Bangladesh, Bhutan, Japan, Malaysia, Nepal, Republic of Korea, Taiwan, Thailand, Vietnam, and United States, apart from India. These initiatives collectively aim to promote inclusive, sustainable, and resilient economic development across the Indo-Pacific region, fostering cooperation, mutual benefit, and peace and security. |
The Inaugural Session was moderated by Mr. Ambarish Dasgupta, Former President, BCC&I and Senior Partner, Intueri Consulting LLP. He stated a famous quote by a geopolitical scholar, Dr. Amitava Acharya, “Asia was built by the nations, Asia-Pacific was built by the economists, East Asia definition was made by the culturalists and Indo-Pacific by the strategists”.
Indo-Pacific has 2 connotations: geographically and geopolitically. The geographic definition defines a vast biogeographic region which comprises the tropical waters of the Indian Ocean and Western- Central Pacific and the seas connecting the two. It comprises of the Indian sub-continent, South East Asia, Oceania, Indian Ocean and the Middle East. The geo-political definition includes many more countries. It extends from the eastern coast of Africa across the entire span of the Indian Ocean to the western reaches of the Pacific encompassing countries such as Japan and Australia.
The esteemed speakers also made discussions on women integration, climate and generic qualities, regional cooperation between the chambers of commerce, food security, service sector improvements to produce better results together.
The discussions were led by:
- Ms. Melinda Pavek, Consul General, U.S. Consulate General, Kolkata
- Ms. Mikiko Tanaka, Head, Subregional Office for South and South-West Asia, United Nations ESCAP (Economic and Social Commission for Asia and the Pacific) General, Kolkata, India
- Mr. Sanjeev Nandwani, East India Chapter Chairperson and Vice President, Indo-Australian Chamber of Commerce (IACC)
- Shri Sanjeev Sanyal, Member, Economic Advisory Council to the Prime Minister (EAC-PM)
- Dr. Devyani Uttam Khobragade, Ambassador, E/I, Phnom Penh, Cambodia
- Smt. Neelam Rani, IFS, Director, Branch Secretariat, Kolkata, Ministry of External Affairs, Government of India
The second half of the Inaugural Session was moderated by Prof. Ajitava Ray Chaudhuri, Ph.D, Professor Emeritus and Head, Department of Economics, Adamas University and Chairperson, Economic Affairs Committee, BCC&I. Some prominent pictures from the opening session are appended below.
Shri Sanjeev Sanyal, Member, Economic Advisory Council to the Prime Minister (EAC-PM) was the Guest of Honour and the expert speaker for the Inaugural Session. In his address he said:
Indo-Pacific is an important framework and we are already beginning to build the financial, physical, economic, and commercial architecture by concrete step by step measures. Indo-Pacific Framework is a maritime concept. The maritime aspect of this is absolutely critical because without taking this into account much of the conversation is meaningless but once we go into a maritime framework then the way we look at the world changes. So once we begin to think in maritime terms we begin to have a far more flexible world view than when we have a landlocked view of the world. So, he is emphasizing in this maritime aspect over and over again because in the end Indo-Pacific is a maritime concept. He added that there is also a financial aspect to the framework. Instead of having rigid financing systems we need to have globally fluid network of financing. Indo Pacific region also has some serious finance hubs. Example Singapore, Tokyo, Mumbai. Interlinking all of these is the key. India intends to internationalize the Indian Rupee over the next decade or so for it to be much more widely used. India aspires to be like other hard currencies like Yen, Pound, Singapore Dollar, and Euro etc. The nation expects that the Indian bonds will be more widely used. India is becoming a more prominent part in the international financial network. |
Dr. Devyani Uttam Khobragade, addressed the session virtually.
She stated that the indo pacific is volubly one of the most strategically important region in the world now. The importance can be underscored by the fact that the region is at the center of global trade and commerce accounting for 65% of the world’s population, 63% of the world’s GDP, 46% of world’s merchandise trade and 50% of world’s maritime trade. India was amongst the first to articulate its vision for the Indo-Pacific. She also quoted India’s vision as laid out by Honorable Prime Minister Shri Narendra Modi which calls for a free open and inclusive order in the Indo-pacific based on respect for sovereignty and territorial integrity of all Nations, peaceful resolution of disputes through dialogue and adherence to international rules and laws. India’s concept of Indo-Pacific is inclusive in nature and supports an approach that respects the freedom of navigation and over flight clearances for all international seas. Further she described India’s relationship with Cambodia and stated that the relationship has achieved a multifaceted character with regular interaction at the political and official levels, exchange of bilateral visits, capacity building and cultural exchange, change of development partnership, assistance towards de-mining efforts and restoration of cultural monuments. Further she elaborated the extent of this relationship by stating that an institutional arrangement is already in place for exploring the integration of Unified Payments Interface with Cambodia. India also wishes to establish a physical connectivity through infrastructure development with further extension of Eastward expansion of the India Myanmar trilateral highway and by negotiating with the investment treaty. |
BCC&I was overwhelmed to listen an overpowering address by Smt. Neelam Rani, IFS, Director, Branch Secretariat, Kolkata, Ministry of External Affairs, Government of India
She stated that, this conclave is an important platform as it will serve as a unified platform for the business community from the Indo-Pacific region to deliberate upon their agendas. This Conclave will prove to be catalyst to enhance business engagements and will further connect the business community in the Indo-Pacific region. The Indo-Pacific region accounts to 63% of GDP and half of all global trade passes through the waters this region. The growing importance of this region on the global geopolitical map and the problem of economic concentration prompted us to intensify our business engagements in the region as India strives for an open free rule-based Indo-Pacific region. India stands for freedom of navigation and respect for international laws in the Indo-Pacific region. De-risking the global economy now involve reliable and resilient supply chain as well as promoting trust and transparency in the digital domain. India pacific region documents call for close cooperation within Indo-pacific countries for improving connectivity in all its dimensions: - transport, digital and human. |
Special Session I: The East in India’s Act East & Common Charter Development
In this session the Chamber brought together various Chambers of Commerce, Leaders representing Industry, Diplomats and Trade Agency Experts from 11 Indo-Pacific countries for the formation of Indo-Pacific Chamber of Commerce (AIPCC).
The organizations which participated were:
- ASEAN-India Business Council
- Bhutan Chamber of Commerce and Industry
- Foreign Investors' Chamber of Commerce and Industry (FICCI), Bangladesh
- Indian Business Chamber in Vietnam (INCHAM)
- Indo-Australian Chamber of Commerce (IACC)
- Japan External Trade Organization (JETRO)
- Korea Trade - Investment Promotion Agency, Embassy of the Republic of Korea (KOTRA)
- Nepal-India Chamber of Commerce & Industry (NICCI)
- U. S. Consulate General, Chennai
- Thailand-India Business Council
- The Chittagong Chamber of Commerce & Industry (CCCI)
- Taipei World Trade Centre
All the participating nations suggested to be more productive by working on shared principles of collaboration, innovation, pioneering, shared learning, teamwork, and trust.
A context of existing trade agreements, supply chain management, air and maritime connectivity especially addressing procedural issues to cross-border trade were some other suggestions. Financial markets, digital integration and wellness could be the other pillars.
People connect (cultural) issues like tourism, work-force training, cross-border labour mobility (including professionals and technicians with special emphasis on youth and gender), collaboration in technology, sustainable energy, creating an educational equilibrium and undertaking a gap analysis customized to the needs of the diverse challenges faced by individual nations in the Indo-Pacific can be some of the key drivers as suggested by the Nations.
Based on these suggestions and the arguments of the meeting a forum was formed titled “Association of Indo-Pacific Chambers of Commerce” (AIPCC) and a Charter was released in presence of the media.
Special Session II: Trade Creation and Market Access Dialogues
The session’s speakers highted on re-building of the global cooperation between the nation states, re-structuring of the supply chain and on shoring of global production networks. India has made a lot of investment for strengthening transport links within the country and also for dedicated trade corridors.
The discussions were led by:
- Dr. Nagesh Kumar, Director and Chief Executive, Institute for Studies in Industrial Development (ISID) (Virtual)
- Mr. Tarun Sharma, Deputy Managing Director, Export-Import Bank of India (India Exim Bank)
- Dr. Prabir De, Professor, Research and Information System for Developing Countries (RIS)
- Mr. Pranav Kumar, Vice President, International Trade Policy & Compliance, Reliance Industries Limited
The Indo-Pacific Economic Conclave 2023 promises to be a milestone event in shaping the economic destiny of the Indo-Pacific region. It reflects the collective vision of nations in the region to create a prosperous, inclusive, and sustainable future for their people.
Day 2: 29th September 2023
The theme for Day 2 of the Indo-Pacific Economic Conclave was “India leads- towards 3rd largest economy”
Day 2 of The Indo-Pacific Economic Conclave on 29th September 2023 witnessed the leaders of our Nation’s economic ecosystem and policy makers on a single platform.
The keynote address was delivered by Shri T Rabi Sankar, Hon’ble Deputy Governor, Reserve Bank of India.
Addressing the Conclave Shri T Rabi Sankar, said, Digital Payment Infrastructure (DPI) to be one of the most important drivers of the Indian Economy. He also mentioned that impact of digital payment systems on cross border payments and its impact will be felt in years to come in cross border payment. As per the World Bank Research, Global cross border remittances in 2022 was estimated to be US$ 830 billion. India was the top recipient of US$ 111 billion. According to World Bank remittance prices Worldwide database, the global average cost of retail size of global remittance was 6.2 % in Q4 2022. For some countries this cost can be as high as 8%. Such a high cost in today’s context when data-connectivity is so cheap is simply unconscionable. I believe that given the available technology, the present situation is not sustainable. In February this year India and Singapore enabled UPI Pay Now linkage to enable the citizens of both countries to make instant and cost-effective cross-border transfers. This inter linkage also aligns with the G20s financial inclusion priorities of driving faster, cheaper and more transparent cross-border payments and will be a significant milestone in the development of infrastructure for cross-border payments between India and Singapore. |
The Conclave was opened to public and approximately 150 people were in the attendance. During the Conclave, the esteemed keynote speakers, Hon’ble Ministers, and other eminent industrialists shared the remarkable growth rates in various sectors of India and also came up with suggestions to lead India towards a 3rd largest economy.
A commemorative address was made by Shri Sanjeev Sanyal, Member, Economic Advisory Council to the Prime Minister (EAC-PM) on the day. In a compelling and visionary speech, Shri Sanyal passionately articulated a vision that promised to breathe new life into the heart of Kolkata. His Concept focused on reimagining Kolkata’s river front through a detailed urban renewal plan focusing on creating a Hooghly corridor featuring a unique pedestrian precinct connect. Modernizing and Syncing tradition with millennia needs and reality was at the core.
Other eminent speakers were:
- Shri Ajay Seth, Secretary, Department of Economic Affairs, Ministry of Finance, Govt. of India
- Dr. V. Anantha Nageswaran, Chief Economic Adviser, Government of India
- Shri Suneet Mehta, Dy Chief of Mission, HCI, Canberra, Australia
- Shri Mayank Joshi, Deputy Chief of Mission, Embassy of India, Tokyo, Japan
- Shri Rajeev Kumar, IPS, Principal Secretary, Department of Information Technology & Electronics, Government of West Bengal
- Mr. C S Ghosh, MD & CEO, Bandhan Bank Ltd. and Former President, BCC&I
- Mr. Shiv Shivakumar, Operating Partner at Advent International, Gurgaon and Ex Chairman& CEO – PepsiCo India and Ex CEO, EM – Nokia
- Shri Rajeev Chandrasekhar, Hon'ble Minister of State, Ministry of Skill Development & Entrepreneurship and Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology, Government of India
Discussions were based on digital public infrastructure, impact of digital payment system on cross border payments, investments to provide better housing and water connections to the people, attention towards skilling, re-skilling and vocational training, empowering women for inclusive growth, promoting technology and PLI schemes.
Shri Ajay Seth, Secretary, Department of Economic Affairs, Ministry of Finance, Govt. of India quoted “India leads towards a 3rd largest economy - is a journey not a goal. That is a means to an end and the end is well-being of our people and a well-developed India.” He presented some data in this regard. Just about ten years back in 2013 India was at the 10th position and the size of the economy were 1.4 trillion. In these 9-10 years India is at the 5th position and the size of the economy is 3.7 trillion. In 1991, India was at the 16th position; the size of the economy was only 300 billion. The implications are huge. The country today has lot more wealth and resources for basic amenities, infrastructure and to facilitate business activities including industries. In the last 7-8 years India added four crore affordable houses. Today there are more than 19 crore houses who has proper water connections. Today the country can aspire and deliver on a saturation approach to basic amenities. There are almost 12 crore households under Swatch Bharat Mission where individual washrooms are there in each house. The country is moving from live to livelihood. Today 50 crore people under various schemes such as PM Suraksha Viman, PM Jibon Jyoti Yojna has insurance cover of the one form or the other. India has been able to achieve a very strong growth rate and a potential to grow faster in the coming years. India contributes to almost 15% of global growth in each year and creates opportunities for global investors and global companies. It also generates a virtual cycle of higher growth leading to higher savings, higher investment, more employment and again coming back to more growth. India’s GST system has led to huge productivity gains and the goods can move with much better efficiency and check post facilities. He listed four sectors which requires attention – energy, skilling and re-skilling, urban infrastructure, and private sectors. A creative re-development of our cities and an orderly transformation to urbanization. He mentioned in this aspect the role of state government is very import for creating reforms in health, education and fiscal consolidation both as expenditure orientation and stepping up the tax efforts. The role of the chambers of commerce as stakeholders are important for India’s development. |
Shri Suneet Mehta, Dy. Chief of Mission, HCI, Canberra, Australia in his address expressed that India and Australia are really coming closer as the India-Australian partnership from June 2020 has created an unprecedented momentum and the business environment is growing more collusive with each passing day. It is already anchored in both the nations desire to increase engagement in the Indo-Pacific, to realize a shared vision for an open free trade prosperous rules-based region that respects sovereignty in terms of mutual commitment. India and Australia are working together to create more diverse and resilient supply chains. Going by the lines of Honourable Prime Minister Shri Narendra Modi, Mr. Mehta also emphasized the development on the 3 T’s i.e., trade, technology, and tourism. In order increase the bilateral trade strategies three strategies are being followed: tariff reductions, expanding market access and diversifying the trade basket. |
Shri Mayank Joshi, Deputy Chief of Mission, Embassy of India, Tokyo, Japan expressed that to become an “Atma Nirvar Bharat” by 2047 the vision should be development on economic infrastructure, demography, democracy, supply chains and energy. Japan has been an important partner for economic development of India. He mainly focused on India- Japan partnership for creating better technological and infrastructure development in India. The two countries are focused to reform multilateralism and are working together closely in important constructs like the United Nations, the QUAD, the CDRI and also the Indo-Pacific framework. As per the information with regard to the Indian government’s production linked incentive scheme, application of 26 Japanese companies with a commitment investment worth of 1.8 billion dollars has been approved. |
Speaking about India’s growth story post COVID at the Indo-Pacific Economic Conclave 2023, Dr. V. Anantha Nageswaran, Chief Economic Adviser, Government of India said that the response and recovery phase is over and now it is all about consolidation. India is poised for good and steady growth for the rest of this decade. Our goal should not be only to become the third-largest economy in aggregate size but also in per capita terms, becoming a middle-income or upper middle-income country, for that we need to make sure that the aspiring middle class is not only able to get the kind of goods and services that they need but they are also in a position to contribute and this is not just a task for the public sector but also the private sector. To prepare the Indian demographic dividend we need right skilling, right education and right attitudes. If MSMEs get paid on time, India will have a vibrant economy and that will eventually be a win for large corporations. |
Shri Rajeev Chandrasekhar, Hon'ble Minister of State, Ministry of Skill Development & Entrepreneurship and Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology, Government of India said, that as per him, we certainly seem to be living in very interesting and exciting times from a global perspective. He stated “almost everyday history is being made, milestones are being crossed. For the first time ever in the history of independent India we have a new parliament, which is a great moment and occasion to celebrate. Two days after the new parliament was released, a law enacted by which historical women’s reservation bill was passed, which will absolutely transform the landscape of opportunities for women and young girls. Two days post that event, iphone 15 was globally launched and at the same day Indian people could also walk in to buy the same phones. The Indian consumers got the “Made in India Iphone 15”, manufactured in India. A $3 billion unit, first ever semiconductor plant, the ground breaking ceremony for that was held in Sanand, Gujrat. India is the fastest growing economy in the world. A country in 2014 who was importing 82% of its mobile phones, had no electronics manufacturing of any kind, is now manufacturing 100% of what it consumes and exported 1 lakh crore Apple and Samsung phones last year. “India is seeing almost 30 startups in semi-conductor device design. We were in the fragile five and here we are now at the top five economies of the world and our Prime Minister has guaranteed that we will move from the top 5 to the top 3 in the next three years. We will cross Japan and Germany and we will be in the league with the US and China amongst the top three economies in the world. Year after year the GST number shows that how the economic growth is not just a statistic, it is creating more and more resources for the Government to invest in infrastructure, in poverty of India to make them move out of poverty, giving them more opportunities. In India there were always lack of modern infrastructure, and here we are today, one of the largest spending nations in world in building modern infrastructure, from rail to roads, to ports to logistics, networks. We are spending 13 lakh crores in this financial year in creating modern infrastructure. The deep transformation changes that has happened for the past 9 years has provided an enabling framework for today’s and future growth.” |
Experts’ Roundtable on: A Discussion on “India Leads- Three Pillars of Success (Agriculture, Manufacturing & Services)”
The industrialist panel provided suggestions on three major sectors – agriculture, manufacturing, and service sectors. The suggestions were to allocate more resources to agricultural research and development to develop new crop varieties, technologies, and farming practices that increases productivity and resilience to climate change; to promote technological education, differential literacy, and STEM (science, technology, engineering, and mathematics) in school; to focus on demand side management and also on food processing system in case of the manufacturing sector.
Eminent speakers of the session-
- Mr. Vijay Deshwal, Chief Strategy Officer and Head of Investor Relations, Aditya Birla Capital Limited
- Mr. Manish Kumar Agarwal, Chief Financial Officer, Indorama India Pvt Ltd.
- Mr. Simarpreet Singh, Director, JIS Group Educational Initiatives
- Mr. Ujjwal Kanti Bhattacharya, Director – Projects, NTPC Limited
- Mr. Abhijit Banerjee, Managing Director, Linde India Limited
Mr. Vijay Deshwal discussed how we have seen the services industry evolve over the last two to three decades and where we see it going forward. According to him, there are now there are other services like healthcare, education centres, etc, which can still be at the forefront and where we see a large opportunity coming through.
Mr. Manish Kumar Agarwal in his address talked about how India has come a long way since Independence on the agricultural front development, and productivity, and this rapid advancement in technology is also helping Indian industry but still India faces a lot of challenges in the agriculture sector contributing to the agricultural economy.
Mr. Simarpreet Singh conveyed the message that, education in India is slowly adopting technology and the rate is much slower than other sectors like banking and agriculture.
Mr. Ujjwal Kanti Bhattacharya in his address said that, the manufacturing sector has dwindled and it must come up if we need to have sustainable service, agriculture, and manufacturing-driven export-oriented economic growth which ultimately adds to the pathway of India becoming a developed country by 2047.
Mr. Abhijit Banerjee said that, over the last few years, we have seen substantial investments coming in on the back of the PLI Schemes, which we believe that the government should continue and that would eventually have a rebounding effect on the economy. And in terms of scaling, we need to ensure that our biggest asset i.e. our population does not become a big liability to us.